MPIRICALLY SUPPORTED THERAPY RELATIONSHIPS
作者: STEERING COMMITTEE / 6742次阅读 时间: 2012年7月21日
标签: 循证医学 治疗关系 有效成分
www.psychspace.com心理学空间网心理学空间A9rc-i4j l!f3R&H |

EMPIRICALLY SUPPORTED THERAPY RELATIONSHIPS: CONCLUSIONS AND RECOMMENDATIONS OF THE DIVISION 29 TASK FORCE

p$jV(i.zsk0

*rj1{y{$n C0STEERING COMMITTEE1

}?"[E,L nC5I0

^N2RXF.? b/E}*@T0'Steven J. Ackerman (student member), Lorna Smith Benjamin (University of Utah), Larry E. Beutler (University of California-Santa Barbara), Charles J. Gelso (University of Maryland), Marvin R. Goldfried (SUNY-Stony Brook), Clara Hill (University of Maryland), Michael J. Lambert (Brigham Young University), John C. Norcross (chair), David E. Orlinsky (University of Chicago), and Jackson Rainer (liaison to Publication Board)心理学空间I"h^Y4Va;v4[CJW

心理学空间+oX&z6v S0a.eI6`|2}

Conclusions of the Task Force心理学空间*o!^3hO2a#Or

  • The therapy relationship (as defined in the opening article) makes substantial and consistent contributions to psychotherapy outcome independent of the specific type of treatment.
  • Practice and treatment guidelines should explicitly address therapist behaviors and qualities that promote a facilitative therapy relationship.
  • Efforts to promulgate practice guidelines or evidence-based lists of effective psychotherapy without including the therapy relationship are seriously incomplete and potentially misleading on both clinical and empirical grounds.
  • The therapy relationship acts in concert with discrete interventions, patient characteristics, and clinician qualities in determining treatment effectiveness. A comprehensive understanding of effective (and ineffective) psychotherapy will consider all of these determinants and their optimal combinations.
  • Adapting or tailoring the therapy relationship to specific patient needs and characteristics (in addition to diagnosis) enhances the effectiveness of treatment.
  • The following list embodies the task force conclusions regarding the empirical evidence onGeneral Elements of the Therapy Relationshipprimarily provided by the psychotherapist. Definitions and examples of each element are provided in the respective articles. 
心理学空间$L%]^P(UD]&l

Demonstrably Effective心理学空间2s C&kHm1~+G*Tl

心理学空间%Z'n&xiG/a

Therapeutic Alliance

SY{t6e.M md}f0

X,@G`@K B0Cohesion in Group Therapy

Q/_G!i?(\7{x0心理学空间oTH+Mn2UG4g5I

Empathy

:V"X6QJ];r'\0心理学空间z$S4M'`*G

Goal Consensus and Collaboration心理学空间t2lj i!j$Nbk|

心理学空间*fuo6Q+z

Promising and Probably Effective心理学空间#r}Ox9nW

心理学空间7E QA H9y:S9H2hsW

Positive Regard心理学空间1_ ]$e$A%j]*oc/R

Ty g)i(a/jOa-x%z0Congruence/Genuineness心理学空间HMSAT E b ]

{7X.ZM)g:^0Feedback心理学空间 [.DxPP'eL%jn

心理学空间C,y.yx3J4D7Q^:U

Repair of Alliance Ruptures 心理学空间 v(C ` `KZ s

心理学空间?1BK.u^h&kq9{&UY*V

Self-Disclosure心理学空间9CI hH l;SZ$E_

!E6[(uQTo0Management of Counter-transference

4H2Ld@'S0

i#]'AGy4N|0Quality of Relational Interpretations心理学空间z#A \X*B"aomur

  • The following list embodies the task force conclusions regarding the empirical evidence on Customizing the Therapy Relationship to Individual Patients on the basis of patient behaviors or qualities. For example, clients presenting with high resistance have been found to respond better to self-control methods and minimal therapist directiveness, whereas patients with low resistance experience improved outcomes with therapist directiveness and explicit guidance. Definitions and examples of the following patient characteristics are provided in the respective articles. 
心理学空间~1Tn9V2q

Demonstrably Effective as a Means of Customizing Therapy

E J;A P#n"T0心理学空间 Bc R l&\Zc`#aZ#N

Resistance心理学空间Aa.O_S

心理学空间cki y]c,X

Functional Impairment

1b b;`B6M5^ V8vU!u0

&^0^2{2h-sp.e|0Promising and Probably Effective as a Means of Customizing Therapy

"M7VXcuR+kZ0

vp3A_Z/@n1F5Q3G ]0Coping Style心理学空间|jjh9N/E

心理学空间Y_'U%TQig1G-[(hR

Stages of Change心理学空间]8Z\c h7k!]I/n

N@'E!P z+A,U(B%^0Anaclitic/Sociotropic and Introjective/Autonomous Styles

9D Kh B/|%E9W?&a5{0

K"n]xW0Expectations

C&{ o#DH3^%}+R2mf.k0心理学空间5A ~f1u[ Z/m&k

Assimilation of Problematic Experiences心理学空间9FU7hh7I:^.ZaJ!`

  • Current research on the following patient characteristics is insufficient for a clear judgment to be made on whether customizing the therapy relationship to these characteristics improves treatment outcomes. Definitions and examples of the following patient characteristics are provided in the respective articles.
心理学空间lG+Az,z&th

Attachment Style

es4q$QBd0

+fy9O5vW%z M0Gender心理学空间o;A^6[3xn |

|J1|Y2Wf.O`0Ethnicity

1QqW~1K0心理学空间,x%@l7f Y6k

Religion and Spirituality心理学空间;m:d}(w/UWvu K

(g"qw[/Ek2O'b!L0Preferences 心理学空间d u]%cA

F2wb"mq(?3TK!K)L0Personality Disorders

N^D9UyI9{0
  • The preceding conclusions do not by themselves constitute a set of practice standards, but represent current scientific knowledge to be understood and applied in the context of all the clinical data available in each case.

e9@WHe-t8v'T0Recommendations of the Task Force

RywSMv0心理学空间W+PS3I7unM

General Recommendations心理学空间pYn_z;x

  1. We recommend that the findings and conclusions of this task force be widely disseminated in order to enhance awareness and use of what "works" in the therapy relationship.
  2. At the same time, readers are encouraged to interpret these findings in the context of the limitations of the task force's work, as explicated in the opening article of this report.
  3. These findings and conclusions represent initial steps in aggregating and codifying available research. We recommend mat future task forces be established periodically to review these findings, include new elements of the relationship, incorporate the results of non-English publications (where practical), and update the conclusions.

a'O(r0[kh0Practice Recommendations心理学空间-LZc Mv)e;V

  1. Practitioners are encouraged to make the creation and cultivation of a therapy relationship characterized by the elements found to be demonstrably and probably effective in this report a primary aim in the treatment of patients.
  2. Practitioners are encouraged to adapt the therapy relationship to specific patient characteristics in the ways shown in this report to enhance therapeutic outcome. 
  3. Practitioners are encouraged to routinely monitor patients' responses to the therapy relationship and ongoing treatment. Such monitoring leads to increased opportunities to repair alliance ruptures, to improve the relationship, to modify technical strategies, and to avoid premature termination. 
  4. Concurrent use of empirically supported relationships and empirically supported treatments tailored to the patient's disorder and characteristics is likely to generate the best outcome. 

q`{e5h)`/fh9sQ0Training Recommendations

2h s+EY5KtT2@]1CtA0
  1. Training programs in psychotherapy are encouraged to provide explicit and competency-based training in the effective elements of the therapy relationship.
  2. Accreditation and certification bodies for mental health training programs are encouraged to develop criteria for assessing the adequacy of training in empirically supported therapy relationships in their evaluation process.
  3. Both graduate training and continuing education programs are encouraged to offer modules on empirically supported therapy relationships and on systematically adapting the therapy relationship to the individual patient.
心理学空间v7om&D fD p

Research Recommendations

|io X.It0
  1. Researchers are encouraged to examine the specific mediators and moderators of the links between demonstrably effective relationship elements and treatment outcome.
  2. Researchers are encouraged to progress beyond experimental designs that correlate frequency of relationship behaviors and outcome measures to methodologies capable of examining the complex associations among patient qualities, clinician behaviors, and therapy outcome.
  3. Researchers are encouraged to avoid a "therapist-centric" view of the therapy relationship and to study both patients' and therapists' contributions to the relationship and the ways in which those contributions combine to impact treatment outcome.
  4. Although the cumulative research convincingly shows that the therapy relationship is crucial to outcome, relatively little is known about how to create and sustain the relationship and about why the relationship works. These are vital questions for future research.
  5. Observational perspective (i.e., therapist, patient, or external rater) is a fundamental consideration that ought to be addressed in future studies and reviews of "what works" in the therapy relationship. Agreement among observational perspectives provides a solid sense of established fact; divergence among perspectives holds important implications for clinical practice.
  6. Since many of the important variables reviewed in this report are not subject to randomization and experimental control, we rec-ommend that standard research paradigms include the use of rigorous qualitative methods and statistically controlled correlational designs.
心理学空间/dw Z h2^]7nAh

Policy Recommendations

SL ul!x0tHb3N,K0
  1. The APA Division of Psychotherapy is encouraged to educate its members and leaders in the benefits of empirically supported therapy relationships.
  2. Mental health organizations as a whole are encouraged to educate their members about the improved outcomes associated with using empirically supported relationships along with evidence-based treatments.
  3. Finally, we recommend that the APA Division of Psychotherapy and mental health organizations advocate for the research-substantiated benefits of a facilitative and individually responsive human relationship in psychotherapy.
www.psychspace.com心理学空间网
TAG: 循证医学 治疗关系 有效成分
«探寻获得人际自我意识的人际模型 问诊策略与技能
《问诊策略与技能》
咨询师倾听技术的定义、目的和步骤»
延伸阅读· · · · · ·
查看全部回复